show all
Thursday, September 2, 2010 | 23:11 Beirut Subscribe to NOW Lebanon RSS feeds
   
Counting the cost
NOW Staff , June 30, 2008

So the rumors are true, and Lebanon will soon be welcoming back, among others, Samir Kantar, held in an Israeli prison these past 29 years. Hezbollah is already trumpeting the deal as another major victory for the Resistance and, no doubt, a vindication of the kidnapping operation that precipitated the July War of 2006.

On paper, Hezbollah appears to have the better deal. Assuming they are dead, Hezbollah will give Israel two bodies in exchange for five “live” Lebanese and an unspecified number of Palestinians detainees. So, two years later, the abduction of Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser has done exactly what it was intended to. Mission, as they say, accomplished.

At least, that is the picture being painted by Hezbollah officials today. But viewed in proper perspective, this is creative accounting at its most tasteless. The prisoner swap is not the whole deal, just the final clause. Conveniently forgotten are the reams of gory appendices in a much larger and bloodier contract written out almost exactly two years ago, with all of Lebanon as collateral. Indeed, the full audit is still ongoing.

How much is the Resistance’s pledge worth? Add to the two Israeli bodies the bodies of 1,200 Lebanese civilians, nearly 400 of them children under the age of 13, sacrificed by Hezbollah to secure Kantar’s return. Add to that the 4,400 wounded civilians, of whom almost 700 are permanently disabled. Add to that those killed and wounded, most of them children, by the cluster bombs still littering large swaths of South Lebanon. Add to that the billions of dollars in destroyed homes, infrastructure and livelihoods.

In the final tally, Kantar – whose alleged taste for violence far exceeds the remit of the typical heroic freedom fighter – is a very expensive man. For make no mistake, his release is the sole profit weighed against the thousands of Lebanese dead and wounded. The four other Lebanese prisoners to be released were themselves captured on his account during the July War, and the number and names of the Palestinians to be freed are entirely at Israel’s discretion.

So Kantar will be freed, and Hezbollah’s word is once again proven to be Lebanon’s bond. We hope and pray that any Lebanese prisoners still held in Israeli jails come at a cheaper price in the future. If each is as expensive as Mr. Kantar has been, they may find themselves heroically repatriated to a desolate wasteland.

Bookmark this article:
Digg  Facebook Google StumbleUpon StumbleUpon Delicious
Comments ( 21 )
Posted by
essam
July 3. 2008
Ya Omar, I hold, like millions of Lebanese of `all sects the hope that IS the case...BUT then, talk is free & decision may not be in their hands !!!..NO one can ever claim to be DIVINE and you know that, this is saying they got it directly from GOD, come on Omar...their silly propaganda state that ALL the time..and I do agree the time is NOT right to 'merge' their weapons within the National Army AND BE UNDER ITS COMAND, not be name only !..also ya Omar, yes OMAR, I don't insult anybody,even the ones that deserve to be insulted, Hizbo cos of limited space allowed.. I also hope some people can come round to your way of thinking !!
Posted by
sami
July 3. 2008
When Essam calls HA as hizbo, he thinks in his own mind that he is insulting the resistance.
Posted by
OmarS
July 3. 2008
Essam: Inshallah, when we achieve all those goals as we say in Arabic: on my head and eyes! and you will find HA will disarm within the frame of a national defence strategy.But talk of disarming now is ludicrous in the face of the threat we face. HA has never claimed to be divine so pls no baseless accusations. Secular war experts described their victory as extraordinary, but those who believe in God know this was a DIVINE victory indeed.
Posted by
essam
July 3. 2008
Shirin...you must know that what Hizbo & Co,and the others for that mater, would say whatever & use religion whenever to cover up their failed policies & so called achievements..No sane person would believe that destroying a Nation is justified for the sake of getting some prisoners released..the 2006 war was to delay any possible attack on Iran,Hizbo will never admit a mistake as they are DIVINE...although they happen to forget Syed Hassan admission that had he knew the response wouldn't have provoked Israel..big bloody deal, you make a mistake & ALL pay the price.
Posted by
essam
July 2. 2008
Shrin..Kantar is 110% Lebanese, his action shouldn't be reasons to deny this fact..Lebanon will never be totally Islamic nor Christian.....Prof. Sami..names used in this discussion can be false, this show how easily u could be led..!! ..Omar, you are right in some respect, but I don't agree that we shouldn't have peace treaty & normal relation with Israel, if all Arab world have/will do so...the benefits to Lebanon will be huge, let the people Vote when & If this issue is raised..also,NO one in his right mind deny the fact of the Resistance acheivment, but then when we get Shabba plus water rights,airspace,land-mines maps..etc) then Hizbo's weapons MUST be under the "proper" control of the national Army,Do u agree ?
Posted by
OmarS
July 2. 2008
Jay: you dont know what you are talking about, and we dont need israeli apologetics in Lebanon for their history of UNPROVOKED aggression and terrorism in our land is unparalled. I am not a follower of wilayat al faqih nor do I await a "shia mahdi". I am muslim and believe in the teachings of the Quran and the Prophet's SUNNAH. That means enjoin good, and most of all refrain from causing strife in the land. Hence my allegiance to HA even if im not shia
Posted by
OmarS
July 2. 2008
Essam 7abibi: the facts do hurt 4 some but they should not The only reason Israel does not occupy most of Lebanon today is because of the armed, noble resistance. HA has already agreed to help in retrieving leb prisoners out of Syria (see Mem of understanding with FPM) As for peace with Israel, totally unacceptable, no group of people has the right to establish a racist state in this region be they jew, muslim or christian.
Posted by
sami
July 2. 2008
Shirin, Kontar is Lebanese, he is NOT a Shiaa, he is a Derzi and belonged to the Communist party which at one time fought the Muslims in Lebanon.HA is in the business of liberating Lebanese land and man from Israeli hands, and defending our homes against the Israeli attacks that lasted more than 60 years.I am amazed that you do not want to defend your home nor will you let others defend, instead you ask them to leave to Afghanistan.
Posted by
shirin
July 2. 2008
Essam, it is the Hizb that declared that Antar release is a triumph for the ilsamic world and lebanon! and this was broadcast on CBC canadian channel!! to the shame of all lebanese!! it is HA that talks as if lebanon is an islamic coutnry regardless of other confessions. the world thinks that antar such a notrious terrorist is lebanese when we all know that he is noi even lebanese and yet all Lebanon had to pay the price for its release by a war provoked by HA. and who am i to have such leverage to create love or hate? it is HA and its actions that is polarising the nation. Face it!
Posted by
sami
July 2. 2008
How ignorant can you be Jay?Omar is a Sunni and does NOT believe in welayet al fakeeh.Some research on this subject is in order.The "capture" not the kidnapping of the two Israeli soldiers was a reaction to the capture of our soldiers.The 2006 was was planned way before this capture....Israel said so, and the USA said so, yet those so called Lebanese insist that this destruction to Lebanon was done by HA.Shame
1 | 2 | 3 |
username or email
password