show all
Thursday, September 2, 2010 | 22:21 Beirut Subscribe to NOW Lebanon RSS feeds
   
Moving the goal posts…again
June 20, 2008

During the Israeli withdrawal from South Lebanon in the summer of 2000, the discovery that the hitherto unheard-of Shebaa Farms was the only slither of Lebanese territory still occupied — and thus still meriting the existence of the Resistance – sent the United Nations scrambling for its maps.  This tiny plot of land had never been mentioned before by Hezbollah, but now, it was elevated to the raison d’être for continuing its guerilla war against Israel.  Skeptics cried foul, arguing that Shebaa was just a convenient excuse for Hezbollah to keep its arms.  This week, they were proven right.

Hezbollah MP Hassan Fadlallah on Thursday vowed that the Shia militia will maintain its arms, even if Israel pulls out of the disputed Shebaa Farms area. One expects that, for Hezbollah’s Syrian and Iranian allies, the resolution of all pending disputes between Lebanon and Israel will not convince them to relinquish their armed struggle (which, by the way, earlier this week appeared to be spreading ominously within Lebanese territory).

As the international community tries to resolve the disputes between Lebanon and Israel in an attempt to pave the way for some kind of peace, Hezbollah uses Israeli concessions as justification to continue its endless war.  An Israeli withdrawal from the Shebaa “would be a big achievement for the Resistance, for this would be the result of its role and its pressure,” according to Fadlallah.  Given this logic, the success of the “resistance” would justify opening new fronts and trying to achieve new concessions rather than returning to the institutions of the state.

So, if Hezbollah and Israel, as expected, soon carry out a prisoner exchange that would return Samir Kantar, among other Lebanese prisoners in Israeli detention, in exchange for Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser, the two Israeli soldiers whose kidnapping sparked the catastrophic war in July 2006, expect Hezbollah to portray this deal as the über-justification for continuing its reckless and destructive posturing against Israel.

As Hezbollah releases unilateral statements regarding the Shebaa Farms and negotiates with Israel over a prisoner swap, the Lebanese government still remains paralyzed over the formation of a cabinet.  Recent reports indicate that the reason for the delay lies in Hezbollah’s insistence on a ministerial policy statement endorsing the militia as a “national resistance.” The country can hover on the edge of the abyss, but Hezbollah doesn’t care. As usual, it wants its parochial demands met and to hell with the rest of us. As for a cabinet, don’t hold your breath.

There should no longer be any doubt: Hezbollah is more than willing to subordinate the Lebanese state to its resistance activities.  When South Lebanon was still under Israeli occupation, this tradeoff was understandable.  Before Hezbollah intimidated its domestic rivals into political concessions through the force of arms, it was perhaps conceivable that the Party of God could exist beside the state.  But today, we are fast moving to a stage where Lebanon is not big enough for both Hezbollah and Lebanon’s national institutions.

Thus the state, as ever, remains secondary to Hezbollah’s chronic navel-gazing. It remains to be seen how and when it will end. The outlook does not look bright.

Bookmark this article:
Digg  Facebook Google StumbleUpon StumbleUpon Delicious
Comments ( 28 )
Posted by
Cedars
July 8. 2008
All SSNP (sami) think a like, they will be told what to think/say.
Posted by
essam
July 1. 2008
this show your high level of Education & knowledge, in fact the any thing of real life....the likes of you not able to think for themselves ...wake up & face reality ...
Posted by
sami
July 1. 2008
you bore me.
Posted by
essam
June 30. 2008
Prof. Sami ..any one read your statements/comments come to the same conclusion as mine...or may be its the way you put your comments across, cry foul when caught !
Posted by
sami
June 29. 2008
The Kurds also are collaborating with Israel but they are NOT Christians ya Einstein Essam.I am only stating facts.The Kataeb (Maroonis)collaborated with Israel and so did members of SLA who were Shiaa as well.Traitors know no sect, and you need to stop putting words in my statements.Read the facts and draw your own conclusions.
Posted by
sami
June 28. 2008
Furthermore Charbel, you are claiming that Israel is defending their land, so Shibaa farms are Israeli now in your eyes?Even Israel itself says that this land belong to Syria and does not claim it.Israel itself is negotiating with Syria and Palestine to give BACK the land it occupied back in '67.Charbel, are you trying to give land to Israel it wants to give back?Are you really saying that Israel attacked Lebanon more than 50 years ago?(1948 till now is 60 not 50 years ago).Did you forget anakeed al ghadab?Tafahum Neesan?The occupation of Beirut in '82? all those are 50 years ago?You people need an education in the Arabic politics.
Posted by
essam
June 28. 2008
Sami,..you & any one that use religion & sect to cover up their faults aren't worth living in this world...if you are implying that Christian are traitors than you need ......traitors have nothing to do with religion/sect...shame on you
Posted by
sami
June 28. 2008
Charbel ya habibi,Israel was DECLARED a state in '48 but it did attacked the Palestinians and the Lebanese frontier since 1947, it did not change any of its aggressive policies and have been attacking and occupying parts of Lebanon since.Unless you live on another planet you should have heard of those consistence attacks even before HA existence.Dont they have access to the Internet and Goggle in your planet?Lebanon is no longer a Christian country thanks to Syria and Iran.One more fact for you, the Christians in Iraq were 1.3 million before the invasion, now they are 700 thousand.The first Iraqi officer to kidnap a fighter Russian made Jet was a Christian who took it to Israel in'66...in '67 the Arab air force was destroyed by Israel.Any correlation between the two?
Posted by
Charbel
June 28. 2008
Sami...you say Israel attacked Lebanon in 1947 LOL...Israel didnt even exist in 1947...AND about the attack IT WAS more than 50years ago... their agenda has changed alot since then... I am not defending Israel they are the cause of alot of problems in the middle east BUT more importantly today they only want to defend their ''land''... WHAT you dont understand is that hezbollah is wrokin on irans agenda and want lebanon to become a frontier to fight and eliminate israel AND then they want to islamize our country which we will never let happen
Posted by
sami
June 28. 2008
Charbel, educate yourself and do more research, how many countries are there in this world, you name 2-3 countries that classify HA as terrorists while the rest of the world including France do not.Dont you find this strange?And please, we have one Michael Hayek, we do not need another telling us what will or will not the EU vote for.Meanwhile i like to inform you that Israel attacked Lebanon since 1947 way before HA existed or had weapons, giving up its weapons will not stop Israeli aggression.As for Shirin invitation for us to leave to Syria or Iran we invite her to immigrate to Israel
1 | 2 | 3 |
username or email
password